T 1024/18 – Another Turn of Events for Description Amendments
This decision appears to bring description amendments back to requiring amendments to the description to conform with any amended…
Since 1997, to obtain patent protection in Hong Kong an applicant had to base the Hong Kong patent on a Chinese patent application, a European patent application which designated the UK or a UK patent application.
This system provides for a two-stage registration procedure. A request to record the Chinese patent application, European patent application which designated the UK, or UK patent application in Hong Kong has to be made within six months of the publication of the respective application. And then a request for registration of the patent that was granted on the recorded application was required within six months of the date of grant of that patent. Provided both steps were taken, a standard patent in Hong Kong was normally granted within three months of the request to register, and the details published.
A new Hong Kong patent system was launched on 19 December 2019 which provides for so called original grant patents (OGP). Under this system an applicant files an application directly with the Hong Kong Patents Registry with the specification in either English or Chinese.
The OGP system will then operate in a manner which is very similar to the Chinese system under which examination must be requested, the application will be examined (initially by the Chinese National Intellectual Property Administration (CNIPA), as an interim arrangement) and will be granted if the examination requirements are satisfied.
The OGP system will operate in parallel with the older re-registration route. So there now is a choice between both routes for obtaining patent protection in Hong Kong. In many cases the existing re-registration system will satisfactorily serve applicants who will be seeking protection in China or the UK in any event, but filing directly in Hong Kong under the OGP system may provide maximum flexibility (but potentially at an increased cost).
However, perhaps the bigger issue is: should an applicant apply for a Hong Kong patent? What are the benefits of doing so and are there any advantages to securing a Hong Kong patent that may not be immediately apparent to a casual observer?
In our view, the answer to all of the above questions is a resounding: Yes!
Firstly, it must be remembered that the patent system in China is relatively young compared to the patent systems in most of the largest economies in the world. The first patent legislation commenced in 1984. In 1985, China acceded to the Paris Convention and then acceded to the Patent Cooperation Treaty in 1994. China became a member of the TRIPS agreement in 2001 when it joined the World Trade Organisation.
Although the consensus view of China’s enforcement of IP rights has improved or stayed the same over the last five years, the system is far from being user friendly, particularly from the point of view of foreign applicants.
As the following graphic shows, the most important challenges identified by companies in China are identified as difficulty prosecuting IP infringements in court or via administrative measures, and insufficient protection offered by text of IP-related laws and regulations.
One-third of respondents cited insufficient protection and difficulty prosecuting IP infringements as their top IP challenges.
Many were also concerned about IP theft by employees, cyber-theft and licensing constraints.
Given these difficulties and the uncertainty of the Chinese system, a Hong Kong patent can provide the key to a strategy regarding enforcement of patent protection in relation to China.
To explain: the evidence points to an increasing number of companies from China operating in Hong Kong. The number of regional/local offices in Hong Kong with a parent company in mainland China has steadily increased each year from 2014-2018 with the number in 2018 increasing 26% over the number in 2017.
In addition, many Chinese companies now have core financial and/or sale operations in Hong Kong, mainly due to Hong Kong’s position in the past.
Hong Kong has a strong rule of law and an independent judiciary. Many professionals are located in Hong Kong with international experience in gaining and enforcing patent protection.
Further, intellectual property rights disputes can be resolved by arbitration in Hong Kong, something which is very unusual in China.
Lastly and possible most importantly, there are specific arrangements in place for reciprocal enforcement of arbitral awards and civil judgments in Hong Kong and China.
So, all things considered, if China is an important market, patent applicants should give serious thought to obtaining a Hong Kong patent as well as (or instead of) a Chinese patent in order to take advantage of the unique position in which Hong Kong finds itself.
If you would like advice on seeking patent protection, please get in touch to speak to one of our experts.